Review: CCR for Azul Payara (Web Profile) 6.38.0 — Jakarta EE 10 Web Profile

[Copilot]

Review of the compatibility certification request for Azul Payara (Web Profile) 6.38.0 against Jakarta EE 10 Web Profile, per the CCR Review Guidance. No repository files change; this PR records the review outcome.

Verified

• Main Platform TCK — jakarta-jakartaeetck-10.0.0.zip SHA-256 matches the official download.eclipse.org .sha256 sidecar.
• Required standalone TCKs — all 11 for EE 10 Web Profile present, matching accepted references Compatibility certification request for IBM WebSphere Liberty for Jakarta EE 10, Web Profile #642 / Compatibility certification request for Open Liberty for Jakarta EE 10, Web Profile #645: Authentication, Bean Validation, Concurrency, CDI, Debugging, Dependency Injection, Faces, JSON Binding, JSON Processing, RESTful WS, Security.
• Dependent TCK hashes — all 11 SHA-256 values match their official sidecar files (valid point releases, e.g. CDI 4.0.13, Faces 4.0.3, RESTful WS 3.1.2, Security 3.0.0).
• Base URL download.eclipse.org/jakartaee/, both attestation checkboxes checked, Java 11 valid for EE 10.

Needs manual verification (vendor domains unreachable from review sandbox)

• Product download URL (nexus.dev.payara.fish) resolves and matches 6.38.0.
• TCK Results Summary (docs.payara.fish) is public/permanent, product-associated, carries required detail/SHAs, and shows all tests passing.

Points to raise with the filer (non-blocking)

• Specification should be listed as Jakarta EE Web Profile 10 (.../specifications/webprofile/10), not "Jakarta EE Platform 10.0".
• Results Summary markdown link is malformed (split across the (Web Profile) parenthesis); should be a single clickable link.

Recommendation: mechanically complete and correct; conditional LGTM pending human confirmation of the two vendor-hosted pages.

[ivargrimstad]

See PR text and issue comment

[Copilot]

See PR text and issue comment

Confirmed — your issue comment matches the two points from my review: (1) the specification should be listed as Jakarta EE Web Profile 10 (https://jakarta.ee/specifications/webprofile/10), not "Jakarta EE Platform 10.0"; (2) the TCK Results Summary link is malformed (split across the (Web Profile) parenthesis) and should be a single clickable URL for the filer to fix.

No repository files change for this review. The only items still outstanding are the two vendor-hosted pages (nexus.dev.payara.fish product download and docs.payara.fish results summary), which remain unreachable from the review sandbox (HTTP 000) and need a human to confirm they resolve, are public/permanent, carry the required detail/SHAs, and show all tests passing. All mechanically verifiable items (main + 11 dependent TCK SHA-256 hashes, required TCK list, base URL, attestation checkboxes) pass.