Hello,
First, thank you for your great work on Nando Programmer.
Background
I was testing SPI-NOR Chip Erase configuration in the database CSV. According to vendor datasheets (e.g. Winbond W25Q128FW), the command 0xC7 or 0x60 should erase the entire flash memory.
I tried the following configuration in erase com.:
But in practice, Nando Programmer did not perform a full chip erase. Only sector erase commands (0x20, 0x52, 0xD8) are working.
Question
-
Does Nando Programmer currently support Chip Erase (C7h / 60h)?
-
If yes, could you explain the correct way to configure it in the CSV?
-
If not, would you consider adding support?
Proposal
Many common SPI-NOR flashes support Chip Erase. It is much faster than looping 4KB/64KB erases for large devices (64Mb, 128Mb, 1Gb). Adding support (or clarifying config) would be very helpful.
Common Erase Commands by Vendors
Vendor | 4KB Sector | 32KB Block | 64KB Block | Chip Erase
-- | -- | -- | -- | --
Winbond | 0x20 | 0x52 | 0xD8 | 0xC7 / 0x60
Puya | 0x20 | 0x52 | 0xD8 | 0xC7
GigaDevice (GD) | 0x20 | 0x52 | 0xD8 | 0xC7 / 0x60
MXIC | 0x20 | (0x52 optional) | 0xD8 | 0xC7
ISSI | 0x20 | — | 0xD8 | 0xC7
(all require Write Enable (0x06) before execution, and WEL clears after erase finishes)
Motivation
Chip Erase saves significant time when erasing large NOR devices. For example:
If Nando Programmer could support this, it would be a big usability improvement.
Thanks a lot for your consideration!
Hello,
First, thank you for your great work on Nando Programmer.
Background
I was testing SPI-NOR Chip Erase configuration in the database CSV. According to vendor datasheets (e.g. Winbond W25Q128FW), the command
0xC7or0x60should erase the entire flash memory.I tried the following configuration in
erase com.:0xC7(199 decimal)0x60(96 decimal)and set
block size = total sizeBut in practice, Nando Programmer did not perform a full chip erase. Only sector erase commands (
0x20,0x52,0xD8) are working.Question
Does Nando Programmer currently support Chip Erase (
C7h / 60h)?If yes, could you explain the correct way to configure it in the CSV?
If not, would you consider adding support?
Proposal
Many common SPI-NOR flashes support Chip Erase. It is much faster than looping 4KB/64KB erases for large devices (64Mb, 128Mb, 1Gb). Adding support (or clarifying config) would be very helpful.
Common Erase Commands by Vendors
(all require
Write Enable (0x06)before execution, and WEL clears after erase finishes)Motivation
Chip Erase saves significant time when erasing large NOR devices. For example:
W25Q128 (16MB) full erase via
0x20takes many minutes,while
0xC7can complete in tens of seconds.If Nando Programmer could support this, it would be a big usability improvement.
Thanks a lot for your consideration!